Collateral Source Rule by State: Billed vs. Paid Medical Bills in All 50 States and D.C.
Whether a jury hears that insurance paid the medical bills, and whether damages follow the billed or the paid amount, depends on the state. As of November 16, 2026, the table shows each state's rule as read from its statute or court decisions, for every state and the District of Columbia.
The short version
Medical damages limited by statute to amounts paid or still owed (9): Arkansas, Florida, Iowa, Louisiana, Missouri, Montana, North Carolina, Oklahoma and Texas.
The court reduces the award after the verdict, by statute (10): Alaska, Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Idaho, Michigan, Minnesota, New York, North Dakota and Oregon.
A separate rule for malpractice claims (17): Alabama, California, Delaware, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Nebraska, Nevada, New Mexico, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Tennessee, Utah, Washington and Wisconsin.
Elsewhere: the rule comes from court decisions, or from statutes that change what the jury may hear; each state page quotes its own.
The table
Figure 1. The collateral source rule and billed-vs-paid medical bills in every state and the District of Columbia
State | Collateral source rule | Billed or paid |
|---|---|---|
Jury may hear that medical bills were paid or reimbursed (statute) | Not settled by the sources read | |
Court may deduct non-subrogated benefits after the award (statute) | Not settled by the sources read | |
Common-law rule covers insurer write-offs (appeals court) | Full reasonable charges, without write-offs (appeals court) | |
Common-law rule; medical damages now limited by statute | Costs actually paid or still owed (statute) | |
Common-law rule; the insurer’s negotiated discount is not covered | Amounts paid or still owing (court decision) | |
Court reduces the verdict, except for benefits the plaintiff paid for (statute) | Payments, discounts and write-offs kept from the jury (statute) | |
Court reduces economic damages after the verdict (statute) | Not settled by the sources read | |
Common-law rule; covers private insurance and gratuitous write-offs | Medicare and Medicaid: the amount paid; private insurance write-offs still covered | |
Common-law rule covers insurer write-offs | Write-offs by the plaintiff’s insurer count as damages | |
Court reduces the award after the verdict, with exceptions (statute) | Bills already paid: the amount actually paid (statute) | |
Common-law rule; the 1987 statute was struck down | Reasonable value; jury hears charged and paid amounts (newer claims) | |
Common-law rule | No reduction to the Medicare or Medicaid discounted amount | |
Court reduces the award after the verdict (statute) | Not settled by the sources read | |
Common-law rule; court deducts large medical benefits (statute) | Reasonable value; the billed amount may be recovered (court decision) | |
Court admits some collateral payments (statute) | Jury may weigh the bill, the amount accepted, or anything between | |
Not covered by the sources read | Amounts actually paid or still needed (statute) | |
Common-law rule; does not bar billed or paid amounts | Both the bill and the amount accepted go to the jury | |
Common-law rule covers contractual allowances | Contractual allowances kept from the jury | |
Common-law rule, now limited for medical bills by statute | Amount the insurer, Medicare or Medicaid paid, plus cost sharing (statute) | |
Common-law rule | Not settled by the sources read | |
Common-law rule | Not settled by the sources read | |
Common-law rule; not changed outside malpractice | Bills admissible; amounts paid not, but the range accepted is | |
Court reduces the judgment for insurance benefits (statute) | An insurer’s discount is a collateral source, but nothing is deducted where the insurer exercised its lien (appeals court) | |
Court reduces the award on a motion after the verdict (statute) | Not settled by the sources read | |
Common-law rule | Not settled by the sources read | |
Collateral sources inadmissible except as the statute allows | Parties may show the actual cost: amounts paid plus amounts still owed (statute) | |
Common-law rule abrogated for medical damages (statute) | Amounts actually paid or still needed (statute) | |
Not covered by the sources read | Not settled by the sources read | |
Per se rule: collateral payments never admissible | Not settled by the sources read | |
Common-law rule | Not settled by the sources read | |
Statute changed the common-law rule | Not settled by the sources read | |
Common-law rule | Not settled by the sources read | |
Court reduces the award after the verdict, net of premiums (statute) | A provider’s write-off cannot be recovered (appellate court, 2002) | |
Not covered by the sources read | Amounts actually paid or still needed (rule of evidence) | |
Court reduces economic damages after the award (statute) | Not settled by the sources read | |
Defendant may show benefits, except ones the payer can recover (statute) | Both the bill and the amount accepted go to the jury | |
Not covered by the sources read | Amounts actually paid, not billed, with exceptions (statute) | |
Court may deduct benefits after the verdict; jury not told (statute) | Not settled by the sources read | |
Not covered by the sources read | Amount actually paid, where the provider was the defendant | |
Not covered by the sources read | Not settled by the sources read | |
Common-law rule | Amount actually paid kept out (Supreme Court) | |
Common-law rule | Reasonable value, decided by the jury | |
Common-law rule covers private insurance | Full undiscounted bills; discounts kept out | |
Common-law rule; does not cover discounts a provider may not charge | Amount actually paid or incurred (statute) | |
Common-law rule; negotiated rates are not covered | Negotiated charges admissible; gross charge not the expense | |
Common-law rule | Not settled by the sources read | |
Common-law rule covers insurer payments and write-offs | Full reasonable expenses; amounts accepted kept out | |
Common-law rule | Reasonable value; the amount billed or paid is not decisive (appeals court) | |
Common-law rule covers discounts and write-offs | Discounts and write-offs are collateral benefits | |
Common-law rule; the insurer’s payment is not evidence of value | Reasonable value; bills presumed reasonable; payments kept out | |
Rule applied to discounted payments (federal appeals court) | Not settled by the sources read |
Each row was read from the statute or court decision named on that state’s page between November 14 and 16, 2026. The state pages quote the words.
What this changes in a demand
The same bills can support different numbers in different states. Where a statute limits damages to amounts paid or owed, the demand follows it. Where the courts allow the full reasonable value, write-offs may still count.
Verdica’s settlement valuation is built from the records and applies state rules and damages caps where verified. Verdica works in all 50 states.
Frequently asked questions
What is the collateral source rule?
In the words the state pages quote, it keeps payments from a source independent of the wrongdoer, such as insurance, from reducing the damages the wrongdoer owes. Many states have changed it by statute, and courts differ on discounts and write-offs; each state page quotes its own rule.
Which states limit medical damages to the amount actually paid?
By statute: Arkansas, Florida, Iowa, Louisiana, Missouri, Montana, North Carolina, Oklahoma and Texas. Each state page quotes the text and its exceptions.
Which states reduce the award after the verdict?
Alaska, Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Idaho, Michigan, Minnesota, New York, North Dakota and Oregon. In these states the court, not the jury, accounts for collateral sources, with exceptions each page quotes.
This page is general information, not legal advice. Each row was checked against its source between November 14 and 16, 2026. It covers only the statutes and court decisions the state pages name. Read the current law, or ask an attorney licensed in that state, before relying on it.
Verdica
General information, not legal advice. Checked November 16, 2026.