Utah Collateral Source Rule and Medical Bills: Billed vs. Paid
Utah's collateral source rule: common-law rule; negotiated rates are not covered (Gardner v. Norman, 2025 UT 47). Billed or paid: negotiated charges admissible; gross charge not the expense. Here is each rule in its own words, how Utah compares with its neighbors, and what it changes in a demand.
The short version
Collateral source rule: common-law rule; negotiated rates are not covered, Gardner v. Norman, 2025 UT 47.
Billed or paid: negotiated charges admissible; gross charge not the expense, Gardner v. Norman, 2025 UT 47.
Malpractice claims against health care providers: court reduces the award by collateral sources, Utah Code § 78B-3-405.
The collateral source rule in Utah
The Utah Supreme Court described the rule:
“evidence that the expenses were covered by insurance is generally inadmissible because a defendant’s liability for damages cannot be reduced based on compensation the plaintiff received from a third party”
Source: Gardner v. Norman, 2025 UT 47, read on the court’s website.
Billed or paid: which medical amounts count in Utah
It then held:
“We hold that the collateral source rule does not require exclusion of the negotiated charges for Gardner’s medical care.”
Its reason:
“The gross charge does not reflect Gardner’s past medical expenses because neither he nor his insurance were ever obligated to pay that amount.”
Source: Gardner v. Norman, 2025 UT 47, read on the court’s website.
Malpractice claims against health care providers in Utah
In these claims
“(1) In all malpractice actions against health care providers”
“the court shall reduce the amount of the award by the total of all amounts paid to the plaintiff”
Except where the payer can recover:
“No reduction may be made for collateral sources for which a subrogation right exists”
Source: Utah Code § 78B-3-405, read on FindLaw’s copy of the Utah code, current as of January 1, 2025.
How Utah compares with its neighbors
Figure 1. Collateral source rules in Utah and its neighbors
State | Collateral source rule | Billed or paid |
|---|---|---|
Utah | Common-law rule; negotiated rates are not covered | Negotiated charges admissible; gross charge not the expense |
Common-law rule covers insurer write-offs (appeals court) | Full reasonable charges, without write-offs (appeals court) | |
Court reduces the verdict, except for benefits the plaintiff paid for (statute) | Payments, discounts and write-offs kept from the jury (statute) | |
Court reduces the award after the verdict (statute) | Not settled by the sources read | |
Per se rule: collateral payments never admissible | Not settled by the sources read | |
Common-law rule | Not settled by the sources read | |
Rule applied to discounted payments (federal appeals court) | Not settled by the sources read |
A claim that could be brought in more than one state can face different rules; which state’s law applies is a separate question.
The full list is in the collateral source rule by state.
What this changes in a demand letter
How a state treats medical bills changes the number a demand can support.
- Value past medical bills on Utah’s measure.
Negotiated charges admissible; gross charge not the expense, under Gardner v. Norman, 2025 UT 47.
- Malpractice claims follow their own rule.
See section 3.
- Watch the filing deadline.
See Utah’s statute of limitations.
- Fault still matters.
Utah’s comparative negligence rule decides how shared fault reduces the claim.
All of Utah’s rules covered so far are on one page: Utah personal injury laws. Our guide on how to calculate a personal injury settlement demand walks through the full calculation.
Verdica’s settlement valuation is built from the records and applies state rules and damages caps where verified. Verdica works in all 50 states.
Common mistakes about Utah’s collateral source rule
- “Insurance payments reduce what the defendant owes.”
Not under the rule quoted in section 1.
- “Malpractice claims follow the same rule.”
Utah has a separate rule for them; see section 3.
- “The rule is the same in every state.”
It is not, even next door; see section 4.
Frequently asked questions
What is the collateral source rule in Utah?
Common-law rule; negotiated rates are not covered (Gardner v. Norman, 2025 UT 47). The Utah Supreme Court described the rule: “evidence that the expenses were covered by insurance is generally inadmissible because a defendant’s liability for damages cannot be reduced based on compensation the plaintiff received from a third party.”
Are medical damages in Utah measured by the billed or the paid amount?
Negotiated charges admissible; gross charge not the expense (Gardner v. Norman, 2025 UT 47). It then held: “We hold that the collateral source rule does not require exclusion of the negotiated charges for Gardner’s medical care..”
Is there a different rule for medical malpractice claims in Utah?
Yes. Court reduces the award by collateral sources (Utah Code § 78B-3-405).
Where is Utah’s rule written?
In Gardner v. Norman, 2025 UT 47 and Utah Code § 78B-3-405.
This page is general information about Utah law, not legal advice. It was checked against the sources listed below on November 14, 2026. It covers only the statutes and court decisions it names; other statutes and later decisions can change the answer. Read the current law, or ask a Utah attorney, before relying on it.
Sources
- 1Gardner v. Norman, 2025 UT 47legacy.utcourts.gov
- 2Utah Code § 78B-3-405codes.findlaw.com
Verdica
General information, not legal advice. Checked November 14, 2026.