New York Collateral Source Rule and Medical Bills: Billed vs. Paid
New York's collateral source rule: court reduces the award after the verdict, net of premiums (statute) (N.Y. CPLR 4545). Billed or paid: a provider's write-off cannot be recovered (appellate court, 2002). Here is each rule in its own words, how New York compares with its neighbors, and what it changes in a demand.
The short version
Collateral source rule: court reduces the award after the verdict, net of premiums (statute), N.Y. CPLR 4545.
Billed or paid: a provider’s write-off cannot be recovered (appellate court, 2002), Kastick v. U-Haul Co., 292 A.D.2d 797 (N.Y. App. Div. 2002).
The collateral source rule in New York
New York lets the court consider payments from other sources for medical and similar costs:
“evidence shall be admissible for consideration by the court to establish that any such past or future cost or expense”
Life insurance and payments that must be repaid are excluded:
“except for life insurance and those payments as to which there is a statutory right of reimbursement.”
The court then
“shall reduce the amount of the award by such finding, minus an amount equal to the premiums paid by the plaintiff”
And it does so after the verdict:
“Any collateral source deduction required by this subdivision shall be made by the trial court after the rendering”
Source: N.Y. CPLR 4545, read on the official website.
Billed or paid: which medical amounts count in New York
CPLR 4545 does not say whether the billed or the paid amount measures medical damages, and no decision of New York’s highest court on that question was read for this page. A New York appellate court (the Appellate Division) decided it in 2002 for an amount a hospital wrote off after no-fault and Medicare had paid:
“Although the write-off technically is not a payment from a collateral source within the meaning of CPLR 4545, it is not an item of damages for which plaintiff may recover because plaintiff has incurred no liability therefor”
The same decision kept the burden of proving a collateral payment on the defendants. For bills whose payer they did not prove, the defendants
“should not be allowed to reduce their liability by the amount of those additional medical bills”
Source: Kastick v. U-Haul Co., 292 A.D.2d 797 (N.Y. App. Div. 2002), read on the Caselaw Access Project (Harvard Law School Library).
How the reduction is proved in New York
The defendant must prove a collateral source reduction, and the standard is high. A New York appellate court described the statute’s “reasonable certainty” standard as one
“which is more than a preponderance of the evidence but less than proof beyond a reasonable doubt, and which has been interpreted by this Court as meaning clear and convincing evidence”
To get a hearing on the reduction at all,
“the defendant must tender some competent evidence from available sources that the plaintiff’s economic losses may in the past have been, or may in the future be, replaced, or the plaintiff indemnified, from collateral sources”
Source: Firmes v. Chase Manhattan Automotive Finance Corp., 50 A.D.3d 18 (N.Y. App. Div. 2008), read on the Caselaw Access Project (Harvard Law School Library).
Car crashes: New York’s no-fault law
Motor vehicle cases have a rule of their own. In an action between “covered persons” (the no-fault law’s term) for injuries from the use or operation of a motor vehicle in New York,
“there shall be no right of recovery for non-economic loss, except in the case of a serious injury, or for basic economic loss”
The statute defines basic economic loss as
“up to fifty thousand dollars per person of the following combined items”
Medical expenses come first on that list:
“All necessary expenses incurred for: (i) medical, hospital”
Sources: N.Y. Ins. Law § 5104(a), N.Y. Ins. Law § 5102(a), read on a public copy of the New York statutes.
How New York compares with its neighbors
Figure 1. Collateral source rules in New York and its neighbors
State | Collateral source rule | Billed or paid |
|---|---|---|
New York | Court reduces the award after the verdict, net of premiums (statute) | A provider’s write-off cannot be recovered (appellate court, 2002) |
Court reduces economic damages after the verdict (statute) | Not settled by the sources read | |
Common-law rule; not changed outside malpractice | Bills admissible; amounts paid not, but the range accepted is | |
Statute changed the common-law rule | Not settled by the sources read | |
Not covered by the sources read | Amount actually paid, where the provider was the defendant | |
Common-law rule | Not settled by the sources read |
A claim that could be brought in more than one state can face different rules; which state’s law applies is a separate question.
The full list is in the collateral source rule by state.
What this changes in a demand letter
How a state treats medical bills changes the number a demand can support.
- Value past medical bills on New York’s measure.
A provider’s write-off cannot be recovered (appellate court, 2002), under Kastick v. U-Haul Co., 292 A.D.2d 797 (N.Y. App. Div. 2002).
- Expect a reduction after the verdict.
Court reduces the award after the verdict, net of premiums (statute), under N.Y. CPLR 4545. A settlement value has to account for it.
- Watch the filing deadline.
See New York’s statute of limitations.
- Fault still matters.
New York’s comparative negligence rule decides how shared fault reduces the claim.
All of New York’s rules covered so far are on one page: New York personal injury laws. Our guide on how to calculate a personal injury settlement demand walks through the full calculation.
Verdica’s settlement valuation is built from the records and applies state rules and damages caps where verified. Verdica works in all 50 states.
Common mistakes about New York’s collateral source rule
- “The jury reduces the award for insurance payments.”
In New York the court handles it: court reduces the award after the verdict, net of premiums (statute).
- “The full billed amount is what can be recovered.”
Not always in New York: a provider’s write-off cannot be recovered (appellate court, 2002).
- “The rule is the same in every state.”
It is not, even next door; see section 5.
Frequently asked questions
What is the collateral source rule in New York?
Court reduces the award after the verdict, net of premiums (statute) (N.Y. CPLR 4545). And it does so after the verdict: “Any collateral source deduction required by this subdivision shall be made by the trial court after the rendering.”
Are medical damages in New York measured by the billed or the paid amount?
A provider’s write-off cannot be recovered (appellate court, 2002) (Kastick v. U-Haul Co., 292 A.D.2d 797 (N.Y. App. Div. 2002)). CPLR 4545 does not say whether the billed or the paid amount measures medical damages, and no decision of New York’s highest court on that question was read for this page. A New York appellate court (the Appellate Division) decided it in 2002 for an amount a hospital wrote off after no-fault and Medicare had paid: “Although the write-off technically is not a payment from a collateral source within the meaning of CPLR 4545, it is not an item of damages for which plaintiff may recover because plaintiff has incurred no liability therefor.”
Is there a different rule for medical malpractice claims in New York?
The sources read for this page show no separate rule for malpractice claims.
Where is New York’s rule written?
In N.Y. CPLR 4545 and Kastick v. U-Haul Co., 292 A.D.2d 797 (N.Y. App. Div. 2002).
This page is general information about New York law, not legal advice. It was checked against the sources listed below between November 14 and 16, 2026. It covers only the statutes and court decisions it names; other statutes and later decisions can change the answer. Read the current law, or ask a New York attorney, before relying on it.
Sources
- 1N.Y. CPLR 4545nysenate.gov
- 2Kastick v. U-Haul Co., 292 A.D.2d 797 (N.Y. App. Div. 2002)static.case.law
- 3
- 4N.Y. Ins. Law § 5104(a)newyork.public.law
- 5N.Y. Ins. Law § 5102(a)newyork.public.law
Verdica
General information, not legal advice. Checked November 16, 2026.